Key takeaways
- The carriers are not structured alike. Some use employees driving company-owned vehicles, which makes ordinary vicarious liability straightforward. Others contract last mile delivery to independent businesses, which is designed to place a company between the driver and the brand.
- Control is the question that decides it. Contract labels are not conclusive. Courts examine who actually directed the work, and in 2014 the Ninth Circuit held FedEx Ground drivers were employees under California law precisely because of the company's control.
- Outcomes are genuinely split. Some courts have allowed claims against the brand to proceed and juries have found agency; others have held the brand too far removed. Anyone who tells you the answer is obvious has not read the cases.
- The insurance can be thinner than in a big rig case. Where a for-hire fleet consists entirely of vehicles under 10,001 pounds, the federal minimum is $300,000 rather than $750,000.
This guide is written and reviewed by our editorial team to be accurate and current. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Company operating models are described from public reporting and court decisions and can change. Contractor liability law is actively developing and differs by state, so confirm the current position with a licensed attorney. If you are facing an emergency, call 911.